What follows is fiction. It is not based on me or my family. We know what happened to our wise man.
----
I carefully unwrapped all the pieces for the nativity set before I arranged them into a scene. My husband was helping the kids with the outdoor decorations, which gave me a chance to create the scene my way. The kids would rearrange it every day between now and Christmas. I’d stay out of the discussions about whether the lamb should be under the roof to stay warm, how far away the donkey belonged, and if it made more sense to put Mary and Joseph together or on opposite sides of Jesus. I’d simply do it my way first and listen in on those debates later.
My husband had given me the set the first Christmas after our wedding. This would be its 20th year on the same mantle. It was still in excellent condition except that a wise man had been missing for years. What happened to him was still a mystery. There were plenty of theories, some more fun than others. My oldest daughter believed one of her siblings broke him and hid the evidence. My youngest daughter insisted he refused to ask for directions and was off somewhere following the wrong star.
I started with the little shepherd in the field. I wished we didn’t have to imagine so much of his flock. I set the open stable against the wall and centered the holy family within it. I was standing the remaining wise men in their places when my husband came in looking exasperated.
“The kids are still arguing over where to put the lights,” he said, “and they have six strings left. I think it’s going to take us all afternoon.”
I nodded my lack of surprise.
“Looks like I’m just in time,” he said. He opened a drawer in the coffee table and pulled out something lumpy wrapped in red tissue paper. “Here. Open my present now.”
The size and shape of the item, along with his comment on timing, suggested it would fit my nativity set. But I did not get my hopes up. We’d tried and failed to find a wise man that matched two Christmases after he disappeared. I unwrapped it slowly, wondering if I should pretend to by happy with one that clashed horribly with the rest or refuse to display something that would bug me.
The front door slammed as our oldest son entered the house. “We need a ladder to get lights on the roof.”
I looked up from the present. “We don’t have a ladder tall enough to reach the roof.”
“And we’re not buying a ladder just for Christmas lights,” my husband added. Though he shot me a questioning and slightly hopeful glance as he spoke. The man was usually one flimsy excuse from a trip to the hardware store.
I tore away the rest of the tissue paper.
“You found him!?” our son exclaimed.
In my hands was an exact copy of our missing wise man. I felt similar shock.
“We can pretend he’s the same one, but I actually lucked into someone on ebay who has broken several pieces and was selling the remaining ones individually.”
“Cool. I’ll tell everyone you said we have to put the lights on the porch.”
I watched my son retreat to the front door without correcting him on what I’d really said. He was a wily teenager who had likely volunteered to ask about the ladder because he knew we didn’t have one. Then I turned to place my present in his place as I said, “I guess I can’t pretend he’s off tending his camel anymore.”
“You can pretend he’s faster than those other two,” my husband said. “Lazy wise men haven’t even started unsaddling their animals and his camel is already taking a nap.”
I laughed, and I hugged the man who could still make me laugh, the man who had evidently kept looking for something I wanted years after I’d given up.
The front door slammed again. “Mom!? Did you really say I can’t put any lights on the mailbox?”
I felt my husband sigh as he turned towards the disturbance. It was my turn to give him something. “Let me get my coat,” I said, “and I’ll help you all sort out the lights.”
Puzzle #1 – Is the woman in the story arranging nativity set A, B, C or D?
Puzzle #2 – Did her husband replace wise man 1, 2 or 3?